A spare dollar can reduce debt, build a reserve, or fund an account for later. Compare ten broad moves, including employer-match contributions, HSA and IRA funding, additional workplace saving, self-employed plans, taxable investing, and education saving. Each card explains the job and cash or account tradeoffs, then gives one action sequence: when to fund or defer, what to verify before acting, and which exact records to compare together.
Next-dollar fit compares return on the next dollar, tax leverage, access before 59½, and simplicity using your stated accounts, debt, reserve, tax outlook, goals, and working style. Profile filters remove some unavailable routes, but do not verify eligibility, remaining contribution room, affordable amounts, written terms, or whether a change took effect. Use the suggested order to choose what to investigate; then verify current cash needs, official rules, exact plan or account terms, the selected amount, and the first statement or confirmation before relying on the move.
What you can do
- A suggested comparison order, not contribution amounts
- Ten moves spanning debt, reserves, and savings accounts
- Profile filters for stated account access
- Cash-access, fee, and tax-timing tradeoffs
- One fund-or-defer, verification, and comparison sequence
- Exact amount, written-term, and effective-date evidence
Frequently asked questions
What order does it suggest?
A broad comparison order based on your answers about account access, debt, reserves, tax outlook, goals, and working style. A reported employer match receives priority in the model, while other answers shift the remaining moves. The tool does not calculate a household budget, an affordable contribution or payment, verified eligibility or room, or whether a payroll or account change took effect; each card names the exact evidence to collect before relying on the move.
Should I grab the 401(k) match or pay off debt first?
Compare the employer dollars you can earn and retain under the current formula and vesting rules with debt costs and urgency. Keep required payments and usable emergency cash in that comparison. The ranking favors a reported match, but it cannot read your plan documents or decide whether changing payroll would leave this month’s bills uncovered.
Is a 401(k) or a Roth IRA better for me?
Compare the employer match, current contribution eligibility and room, tax timing, fees, investments, and withdrawal rules. A Roth IRA contribution has no current deduction; qualified withdrawals can be tax-free later. Workplace plans may offer pre-tax or Roth contributions. The account name or a high fit label alone does not settle the choice.
What if I have no workplace plan or no match?
Reporting no workplace plan removes plan-dependent steps. Reporting a plan with no match removes only the match step, so additional workplace saving can remain. Other displayed routes still need their own eligibility and account checks; being on the list is not confirmation that you can fund them.
Is this tax or investment advice?
No. This is an educational comparison of savings moves, not a verified contribution plan or a calculation of tax savings. Check current official limits, household cash needs, the exact amount, written plan or account terms, fees, tax treatment, and the first statement or confirmation; get qualified tax or investment help when the decision depends on facts you cannot confirm.
Ready for your recommendation?
The Retirement Contribution Priority runs entirely in your browser. Free, no sign-up required to use it.
Related calculators
Other planning tools that pair well with the Retirement Contribution Priority.